The rest of this post is about baseball, so feel free to scroll down if you're not into that.
I'm going to post who I think should be deserving of making the All-Star Game, and I'm not sure if I'll follow the "every team gets a player" rule yet, and obviously I'm ignoring the fan votes, which were not as bad as they usually are this year. I liked Jewboy's starting lineups, and there's obviously room for a lot of discussion as to who should start and make it and whatnot, but I think a basic case can be made for a lot of players, so please: No fighting, just rational discussion. Explanations will come after the rosters.
Stats will be in Avg./R/HR/RBI(/SB) format, through yesterday, for starters; important stats for reserves. W-L, (SV,) ERA/WHIP, K's in IP for P's. *'s will be placed by players I own or have owned in my main fantasy baseball league.
Let's start with the National League starters:
And now, the American League starters:
- C: Russell Martin, LAD - .302/48/10/57/16
- 1B: Prince Fielder, MIL - .284/62/29/68
- 2B: Chase Utley, PHI - .324/63/15/67/6
- SS: Jimmy Rollins, PHI - .282/71/16/51/15
- 3B: Miguel Cabrera, FLA - .324/52/18/61
- *OF: Matt Holliday, COL - .345/56/15/69/4
- *OF: Eric Byrnes, ARI - .312/53/14/49/17
- OF: Carlos Lee, HOU - .296/47/16/72/6
- *C: Victor Martinez, CLE - .328/44/16/68
- 1B: Justin Morneau, MIN - .292/56/23/72
- 2B: Brian Roberts, BAL - .320/55/5/27/26
- SS: Carlos Guillen, DET - .325/50/13/65/7
- 3B: Alex Rodriguez, NYY - .315/77/29/82/9
- OF: Magglio Ordonez, DET - .367/70/13/70
- OF: Gary Sheffield, DET - .297/76/20/56/12
- OF: Grady Sizemore, CLE - .284/73/15/46/24
- *C: David Ross, CIN - 49% caught stealing
- 1B: Albert Pujols, STL - .309/49/16/51
- 2B: Brandon Phillips, CIN - .277/60/17/47/15
- 2B: Dan Uggla, FLA - .249/67/17/51
- SS: Hanley Ramirez, FLA - .330/70/14/34/27
- SS: Jose Reyes, NYM - .306/61/4/34/44
- SS: Edgar Renteria, ATL - .323/56/10/45/8
- 3B: David Wright, NYM - .293/49/16/51/18
- OF: Adam Dunn, CIN - .260/55/24/58/8
- OF: Ken Griffey, Jr., CIN - .289/49/23/59
- OF: Barry Bonds, SF - .299/46/17/42/5; .517 OBP
- *OF: Hunter Pence, HOU - .341/38/11/41/7
- C: Jorge Posada, NYY - .330/45/9/48
- C: Joe Mauer, MIN - .310/40/4/37/5; 52% caught stealing
- 1B: Carlos Pena, TB - .288/44/20/52
- 1B: David Ortiz, BOS - .317/55/14/51
- 1B: Kevin Youkilis, BOS - .328/50/9/44
- 2B: Placido Polanco, DET - .335/62/3/38/3
- SS: Orlando Cabrera, LAA - .330/55/5/51/10
- 3B: Mike Lowell, BOS - .302/39/14/62
- OF: Torii Hunter, MIN - .304/55/19/68/11
- OF: Ichiro Suzuki, SEA - .358/59/5/39/23
- OF: Vladimir Guerrero, LAA - .325/46/14/75
- OF: Alex Rios, TOR - .295/62/17/52/9
- Jake Peavy, SD - 9-3, 2.19/1.06, 125 in 119.0
- Chris Young, SD - 8-3, 2.00/1.06, 99 in 103.2
- John Maine, NYM - 10-4, 2.71/1.14, 93 in 109.2
- Brad Penny, LAD - 10-1, 2.39/1.19, 82 in 116.2
- Cole Hamels, PHI - 10-4, 3.72/1.21, 124 in 118.2
- Ian Snell, PIT - 7-5, 2.93/1.17, 93 in 116.2
- Takashi Saito, LAD - 23, 1.47/0.71, 47 in 36.2
- Francisco Cordero, MIL - 27, 2.86/1.07, 49 in 34.2
- Jose Valverde, ARI - 26, 2.62/1.08, 38 in 34.1
- Trevor Hoffman, SD - 25, 1.91/0.76, 20 in 33.0
- Jason Isringhausen, STL - 17, 1.57/0.90, 29 in 34.1
- Billy Wagner, NYM - 17, 1.64/0.91, 51 in 38.1
It seems like I have every team but four: WAS, KC, CHC, and TEX. If I had to replace people, it would be Pence with Alfonso Soriano (CHC); Renteria with Dmitri Young (WAS); Neshek with Eric Gagne (TEX); and Youkilis with *Mark Teahen (KC).
- Dan Haren, OAK - 10-3, 2.30/1.00, 101 in 129.1
- *Johan Santana, MIN - 10-6, 2.75/1.03, 125 in 121.0
- *C.C. Sabathia, CLE - 12-3, 3.58/1.17, 119 in 133.1
- John Lackey, LAA - 11-5, 2.91/1.15, 98 in 120.2
- Josh Beckett, BOS - 12-2, 3.44/1.14, 92 in 102
- Justin Verlander, DET - 10-3, 3.14/1.15, 97 in 109
- Kelvim Escobar, LAA - 10-3, 3.19/1.16, 88 in 107.1
- *J.J. Putz, SEA - 24, 0.90/0.57, 43 in 40.0
- Francisco Rodriguez, LAA - 24, 2.33/1.19, 53 in 38.2
- *Jonathan Papelbon, BOS - 20, 1.93/0.86, 46 in 32.2
- Bobby Jenks, CWS - 23, 3.28/1.15, 33 in 35.2
- Pat Neshek, MIN - 3-1, 1.71/0.74, 51 in 42.0
My starters at this point would have to be Peavy and Haren; the guys I'd use to close the 9th are Saito and Putz. The hardest snubs in the AL were Jeter, *Peralta, Guthrie, Bedard, and *Nathan. In the NL, it has to be *Beltran, Soriano, Hawpe, Howard, and Hardy. But it's pretty easy (I think) to understand all of them.
The starters at C, 1B, 2B, and 3B in both leagues are self-explanatory. OF in the NL is a bit trickier. Holliday I think is the best of the bunch and easy to agree on. Lee has driven in 72 runs, which none of the others really come close to. But I chose Byrnes over the others not only because I own him, but because he's been a bit more all-around with both power and stealing bases out of primarily the #1 slot, and with all the hitting measures up for debate, he is clearly the best fielder of the bunch. I would consider putting in Griffey to start if only for the sake of the fans and for old times' sake.
SS in the NL was far and away the most difficult. To start, I put Hardy fifth and therefore out and Renteria fourth. At first I picked Ramirez over Reyes due to his better numbers in every category but stolen bases... and even then, he has 27. But then I compared those numbers to Rollins and couldn't help but make the same comparison - while his average and steals are lower, he still is hitting a solid .282 with 15 steals... and none of the others had the RBIs he did. Moreover, both Rollins and Reyes are better fielders than Ramirez, with Reyes the best of them all; but I had to take Rollins as the most all-around of the three. I think anyone can make a case for any of those three and back it up well.
SS in the AL was tough, but not quite as tough. When it came down to it, Peralta and Jeter simply weren't as good with the bat as Guillen and Cabrera, who are both better fielders than them as well. As a note, Jeter is a highly overrated defensive SS, while Peralta has gone from terrible to very good this year. Apparently, they discovered he was near-sighted and he got LASIK over this past off-season. Guillen was just slightly better than Cabrera in the first half, giving him the starting role.
OF in the AL was a bit trickier. I think Ordonez is simply too far ahead to question; a case could be made for Ichiro's .358, Vlad's 75 RBIs, or Hunter's all-around numbers, and obviously all can play defense, but Sheffield and Sizemore's numbers are both all-around as well, with Sizemore also playing incredible defense. It's also fair to note that however high Ichiro's average is, his OBP is still barely better than either of them, while Hunter's is much lower.
For the backup C's, there was simply nobody in the NL, so I decided "Screw it. I'm taking the guy who can actually play catcher." That's the .195 batting David Ross. They can leave Martin in all game anyway, and use Ross if they need the arm in the 9th or something. In the AL, I don't see how you can take Pudge over Mauer when they have the same numbers despite Mauer missing a month and when Mauer has thrown out the same amount of guys as Pudge (12) while giving up 11 SB's to Pudge's 30.
To backup 3B, Wright in the NL was simple. Lowell in the AL was by default. The only guy close was Casey Blake, whom I love but simply isn't an All-Star. At 2B, Polanco was by default in a terrible AL, while Phillips and Uggla were obvious choices.
Among P's, I wanted to have 12 pitchers, with 5-6 of them relievers, for each league. That's pretty much why Guthrie and Bedard didn't make it, as the only one they could possibly replace would be Escobar, and I debated between Nathan and Jenks for a while. While Nathan's numbers are better, Jenks has 23 saves to Nathan's 16, and I figured with it close enough, I may as well give the Sox one representative. Yeah, it's a bad reason. Honestly, the next best AL relievers? Okajima, *Sherrill, and Betancourt.
In the NL, it was a bit rougher. They had much better closers to pick from, and I could have easily selected a couple of relievers as well (*Heath Bell, Scott Linebrink), but I wasn't going to have more than 6 relievers. The last starter spot was between Snell, Derek Lowe, and Brandon Webb, but it was easy to pick among them. Snell had a better winning percentage with a better ERA, WHIP, and K rate than Lowe, so he was the selection. Webb's WHIP wasn't comparable, and he's been much less consistent - he's had 9 games where he's given up four or more runs. Snell has had just four. Ben Sheets was also a consideration, but his ERA is half a point higher than Snell's with less K's.
So those are my All-Stars. What do you think?